As shoppers have become more conscious about the origins and quality of their food, labels on meat and poultry have become essential guides in making purchasing decisions. Terms like “grass-fed” and “free-range” offer reassurance that the products chosen align with personal values. However, with the USDA’s new guidelines aimed at strengthening the substantiation of these claims, we now face a new challenge: balancing trust in these labels with the rising costs of ensuring their accuracy.
In the past, sourcing food was a personal affair. People knew their farmers and trusted the practices behind the food they purchased. That direct relationship has largely been replaced by labels, which now serve as a proxy for that lost connection. While these labels help bridge the gap between consumers and producers, they also bring new complexities.
The updated USDA guidelines, which encourage third-party certification to substantiate animal-raising and environment-related claims, aim to ensure greater label accuracy and quality. However, for producers to display these certified claims on their labels, they must pay ongoing fees and compliance costs. For some producers, these costs are far from just a minor investment—they can represent a substantial financial commitment, sometimes amounting to tens of thousands of dollars each year or more.
If a producer doesn’t pay these costs, even if they meet the certification standards, they may not be allowed to state it on their label. This not only limits the producer’s ability to fully market the value of their product but also reduces transparency for consumers, who may not get the complete picture of how their food is produced.
In the end, maintaining trust while keeping quality meat and poultry affordable will require thoughtful choices from all of us. By supporting producers who prioritize integrity, we can help ensure that the food on our tables continues to reflect the values we care about, without placing undue burden on consumers.
What are your thoughts on the balance between label accuracy and affordability? We’d love to hear your perspective in the comments below.
Follow the full journey of our Poulet Rouge® Chicken—from eggs in France to 12 weeks of pasture-centered care on Carolina farms.
Another AA for Joyce Farms! Our latest food safety score highlights the pride, care, and commitment that goes into every product we produce.
Food waste is a challenge across the food system—but there are practical ways to do better. On Stop Food Waste Day, we’re sharing how farms, chefs, and home cooks can make small changes that add up to lasting impact.
